The World’s Most Perfect Face: Joan Smalls? Elle says Yes! Golden Ratio says …

In 2014, Elle Magazine announced “Meet the very real woman behind the planet’s most perfect face: It’s Joan Smalls. Supermodels, over? As if. Joan Smalls wields the kind of flawless, unequivocal beauty that is both a throwback to the past and a sign that fashion is finally facing the future.”

The Elle article describes Joan’s background and rise to supermodel status, saying, “The hair is long and straight, the bone structure aquiline, the smile dazzling. No wonder Smalls is kicking up the kind of fashion-industry excitement that comes along only a handful of times each decade. Over the past year, she has snagged the number-one spot on Models.com, having pulled in a rumored $3.5 million—making her the eighth-highest-paid model in the world, according to Forbes.” (Follow her on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter.)

Is “flawless, unequivocal beauty” marketing hype or mathematical fact?

LA Times reporter Rene Lynch was intrigued, but wanted to do some investigative reporting on this claim of “flawless, unequivocal beauty.” Was it just hype? Could it be substantiated? She called on the Phi Guy, Gary Meisner, author of Phi: The Golden Number and developer of PhiMatrix golden ratio design and analysis software to see what some golden ratio analysis would reveal. Gary invited Dr. Stephen Marquardt, inventor of the Marquardt Beauty Mask to collaborate on the analysis.

Rene’s full article with our interview appeared as a front page feature story on beauty in the LA Times as “Puerto Rican model has ‘planet’s most perfect face’? We find out.” Below are some of the results of the facial analysis performed by Dr. Marquardt and I using our respective golden ratio based tools.

Facial beauty analysis based on the Golden Ratio

I analyzed Joan’s face with PhiMatrix software to determine the presence of the golden ratio, the classic marker of beauty, in the proportions of her facial features. Click on any image for the full size image.

On the horizontal measures, the golden ratios found were not surprising for a beautiful supermodel:

• the inside points of her eyes to the width of her face (gold lines)
• the outside points of her eyes to the distance from the center of her nose to the width of her face (white lines)
• the points of her upper lips (cupid’s bow) to the width of her mouth (green lines)
• the width of her nose to the half-width of her mouth (red lines)
• the width of her lateral incisor tooth to the width of her central incisor tooth (blue lines)

The vertical measures were a bit more surprising and atypical. Golden ratios were found at:

• the height of the eyes to the distance from the bottom of the eyes to the top of the eyebrows (gold lines)
• the flare of the nose to the distance from the pupils to the tip of the nose (aqua lines)

The surprising measures were those that showed her face to be relatively long:

• the bottom of the teeth were at a lower point than is often found in the distance from the pupils to the bottom of the chin (green lines)
• the hair line was a higher point than is often found in the distance from the bottom of the eyes to the top of the eyebrows to the hairline (white lines)

Facial beauty analysis based on the Marquardt Beauty Mask

Dr. Marquardt’s analysis with his Beauty Mask revealed similar findings. We noted that in performing the facial analysis, we had to stretch the beauty mask to 108% of its normal height to fit her face. With this revision made, many of her facial components (eyes, brows, cheeks, chin and lips) matched the mask to a striking degree. Having to narrow the mask to be able to fit it to her face immediately tells us she’s not a classic beauty. This confirms the results of the golden ratio analysis above, which also revealed that Joan’s face is relatively longer and narrower than that of most women regarded to have classic beauty.

Even after the vertical stretching, a few of the components of her face were still not completely aligned with the mask and our classic golden ratio beauty measures.  The left side of her face (on the right side of the photo below) was slightly higher than her right side and her lower jaw is rather narrow at the chin lines.

Facial symmetry analysis

Symmetry does not necessarily create beauty, but beauty is sometimes augmented by facial symmetry. If Joan has the “planet’s most perfect face” we might expect to see a high degree of symmetry between the left and right half of her face. This, though, does not seem to be the case. The right half of her face appears to be very slightly wider and higher than the left side. The visual effect of this in mirrored photos can sometimes be exaggerated by a slightly off-center angle of the face to the camera, but it still seems to be true of her face.

There’s more to beauty than what meets the eye

So, as demonstrated from the facial analysis, Joan is unquestionably beautiful, but her face has a number of features that do not merit descriptions of unequivocally “perfect” or “flawless.”  So why does Elle make such a bold claim?  First, there’s the obvious sizzle factor.  Claims like this sell more magazines than “here’s another pretty face we found to put on our next magazine cover.”

Another factor is that you have to consider what constitutes “perfection.” I would contend that there’s much more to Joan’s success and fame than the precise measurements of her facial proportions. As shown in the photos at the beginning of the article, she can very successfully adapt her look and expressions to carry off everything from exotic/mysterious to sophisticated, to the smiling, trendy school girl. Not everyone can do that. More yet, the Elle article describes a personal presence that makes those around her sense a very special quality, a confidence or air, even in the way she speaks.

A key point of this is that true beauty is measured by more than the facial proportions that we analyzed in exacting mathematical detail. It appears that Joan’s deviations from mathematical facial perfection are more than offset by many other qualities that come from her inner strength, beauty, expressiveness and style. That is an important point that anyone who is asking “how can I be more beautiful” should duly note.  Dr. Marquardt’s general research shows that a smiling face conforms more closely to golden ratio proportions than a reposed (no smile) one. A smiling face is certainly far more beautiful than a face with a look of anger or arrogance. Looks can indeed kill, and the victim is most often your own personal appearance.

Inner qualities, cosmetics, personal style and presentation are all part of beauty

Joan’s inner qualities are also profiled in the Elle article, and readers should not let those qualities be overshadowed by the headline-making claims of the physical perfection of her beauty.  Most of their readers cannot change their facial dimensions. They can change makeup, clothing and hairstyles, which all have very real impacts on our perceptions of beauty. They can aspire and learn to change their inner qualities of beauty as well. All these are critical to the beauty of a supermodel, and to everyone else.

Classical beauty versus exotic beauty

After the interview with Rene, Dr. Marquardt and I continued our discussion on non-classical beauty. We both feel that Joan fits well in this category. Joan is perceived as beautiful even though she doesn’t fit golden ratios and the beauty mask perfectly. Why is this? First, we need to acknowledge that no one’s face fits every golden ratio or the beauty mask perfectly. And, according to Dr. Marquardt, the her facial components fit the narrowed beauty mask well, so this still puts her in the realm of being beautiful.

More importantly though, in the world of supermodels classic beauty does not necessarily grab people’s attention. What generates more attention than classic beauty is classic beauty coupled with a tension that results from the conflict of beautiful versus not beautiful, good versus bad, shy versus aggressive, etc. The greater the conflict, the greater the attention and attraction. These kind of faces are classified as exotic and/or striking. In the fashion world, there are many beautiful woman.  So how does a woman stand out from all the others? By having a face that’s both beautiful but conflicted. This results in a visual confusion that causes the tension in their perceptions to rise dramatically. A beautiful face coupled with that contrast, that is what makes a woman beautifully different and intriguing in today’s world of supermodels. That’s what Joan has.

Credentials and References:

Dr. Steven R. Marquardt is the inventor of the patented Marquardt Beauty Mask, profiled on the site he authored, Marquardt Beauty Analysis (www.beautyanalysis.com.)  He received his doctorate from UCLA and completed his residency in oral and maxillofacial surgery at the UCLA medical center. He retired from active surgical practice after 27 years and currently conducts his research on human attractiveness in Orange County, California. Dr. Marquardt is an active member of the Societies of Maxillofacial Surgeons, and a Diplomate of the American Board of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery. His university appointments have included Assistant Research Oral Surgeon and Chief of Facial Imaging at UCLA, and professorships at Loma Linda University as well as at the University of Southern California. Dr. Marquardt’s facial imaging research is acknowledged by professionals worldwide and has been presented extensively in the public media. You may have seen him on CBS, NBC, The Discovery Channel, BBC and The Learning Channel. Newspapers such as the London Times and national magazines including those in the United States, France, Germany, the United Kingdom, Holland, South Africa, Hong Kong and Australia have featured articles on his work. He currently continues his research on attractiveness and teachers lecturing to university students as well as to professionals and public groups.

Gary Meisner is the developer of PhiMatrix Golden Ratio Design and Analysis software (www.phimatrix.com), used in over seventy countries for a variety of applications including art, architecture, design, photography, financial market analysis and cosmetic surgery. He is also the author and developer of the site “Phi 1.618: The Golden Number” (www.goldennumber.net).  This is one of the Internet’s leading sites on the topic of the Golden Ratio, and presents his original research as well as content from a community of dozens of contributors from a variety of academic and professional fields.  The site serves as an online community and resource for those interested in this topic and receives over 1 million visits per year.  His work has been features in the LA Times, an educational documentary on the golden ratio by EBS Docuprime in South Korea, in Da Vinci: The Exibition and other places. Mr. Meisner has extensive business career, serving as CFO and CIO roles for five public companies, as well as a private VC-backed technology company.  He has an MBA from the University of Chicago and BS from the University of Illinois.

Elle article: http://www.elle.com/culture/celebrities/a12642/joan-smalls-profile/

LA Times article: http://www.latimes.com/nation/shareitnow/la-sh-joan-smalls-perfect-face-20140108,0,5402692.story